Imagine… Exploring Homes on Whidbey Island

Walking into an open house should feel exciting—like the beginning of a new chapter. But let’s be real: it can also feel overwhelming. There’s a lot to take in, and it’s easy to get swept up in the charm of a beautiful home without asking the questions that really matter.

On Bainbridge Island, homes come with layers of history, character, and lifestyle choices. That’s part of the magic, but it’s also why I encourage my clients to dig a little deeper. Here are some of the things I’d be asking if I were walking through that front door with you.

Ask About the Story

Every home has one. How old is it? What renovations have been done? Who lived here before? On the island, you’ll find everything from mid-century gems to updated farmhouses. Knowing the story helps you understand not just the condition of the house, but the love (and sometimes neglect) that’s gone into it.

Get a Feel for the Neighborhood

Bainbridge is all about its communities—quiet stretches of forest, walkable town centers, or waterfront neighborhoods with beach access. Ask about the vibe: is it peaceful and private, or bustling with activity? I always say a house has to fit your life, not just your Pinterest board.

Don’t Skip the Basics

Yes, the kitchen backsplash might be gorgeous, but ask about the roof, the plumbing, the heating system. On an island, weather plays a role in how homes age. Knowing the bones of the house keeps you from surprises down the road.

Look Outside, Too

Outdoor space matters here. Is there room for a garden? A deck to watch the ferries? Mature landscaping to maintain (or simplify)? On Bainbridge, the connection between indoor and outdoor living is part of the value.

Think About the Practical Stuff

Utility costs, HOA rules, ferry schedules, commute times—these aren’t glamorous questions, but they matter. A home that looks dreamy on Sunday afternoon might feel different on Monday morning when you’re rushing to catch a ferry.

Keep the Future in Mind

Bainbridge is growing. Ask about planned developments, new schools, or road projects. They can change the feel of a neighborhood—and your home’s value—over time.

A Word on Open House Etiquette

An open house isn’t just about the home—it’s also about respect. A Realtor is hosting you, and their job is to welcome visitors, answer questions, and learn where you are in your home buying process.

If you already have an agent, let them know and share your agent’s name. This keeps everything transparent and ensures smooth communication. If you don’t have an agent, treat this as a chance to connect—ask questions, see if their style fits yours. Sometimes an open house is the perfect place to meet your match.

Maybe you have an agent you love who works outside the area but you trust their network. That’s okay too—just let the hosting agent know that’s your plan.

And yes, if you’re asked to sign in, please do so. It’s not just a formality—it helps the listing agent keep track of activity for their clients. If you don’t want follow-up communication, simply note that on the sheet. Transparency goes a long way and keeps the process professional and respectful.

Why These Questions Matter

Open houses aren’t just about walking through pretty rooms—they’re about imagining your life there. The right questions make sure you’re seeing the full picture, not just the highlights.

When you’re ready to explore Bainbridge Island homes, I’d love to walk through them with you—not just to point out the pretty details, but to ask the questions that matter. Because finding the right home isn’t just about the house—it’s about finding your place in the community.

—Amy Gulden