Island County's October 2026 home sales report looks calm. Closings were up, the median price was slightly higher than a year earlier, and months of inventory stayed near four. A column further along in the same Northwest MLS report shows something else. Pending sales, meaning homes that went under contract during the month, dropped to 90 from 154 in October 2025, a 41.6% decline. The drop was close to that size at every end of the island.
A closing records a contract that was signed at some earlier point. Pending sales count the contracts buyers signed during the month itself. If you're comparing Oak Harbor, Coupeville and Langley this winter, pending sales are the more useful figure. They show that winter supply is looser than the price figures suggest, and the North, Central and South ends are loosening in different ways.
October 2026, Area by Area
NWMLS divides Whidbey into three map areas: South Whidbey is Area 811, Coupeville–Greenbank is Area 812, and North Whidbey is Area 813. The October figures below combine houses and condos and compare October 2026 with October 2025.
| October 2026 vs. October 2025 | South Whidbey 811 | Coupeville–Greenbank 812 | North Whidbey 813 | Island County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pending sales | 25 vs. 47, down 46.8% | 9 vs. 16, down 43.8% | 30 vs. 54, down 44.4% | 90 vs. 154, down 41.6% |
| Closed sales | 39 vs. 35 | 10 vs. 10 | 38 vs. 37 | 116 vs. 111 |
| Month-end active listings | 119 vs. 101 | 52 vs. 48 | 163 vs. 126 | 465 vs. 380 |
| Median sale price | $791,000 vs. $772,000 | $612,499 vs. $695,000 | $507,500 vs. $465,000 | $611,500 vs. $600,000 |
| Months of inventory | 3.05 | 5.20 | 4.29 | 4.01 |
Every column holds the same pattern. Closings were flat or up, active listings rose, and pending sales fell by roughly 40% to nearly 50%.
The Drop Built Over Three Months
The NWMLS breakouts for August and September show the decline building over three months. Countywide pending sales were 158 in August 2026, the same as August 2025. In September they were 124 against 138 a year earlier, down 10.1%. October was the 41.6% drop.
The South End changed the most over those three months. Area 811 went from 52 pending sales in August 2026 against 43 a year earlier, up 20.9%, to 32 against 49 in September, down 34.7%, and then to October's 46.8% decline.
Whidbey followed the region. Across the full NWMLS service area, October pending sales fell 17.8% to 5,541, the fewest for any October since at least 2014 and the sharpest year-over-year decline of 2026. For every 100 new listings in October, buyers went under contract on about 69 homes, down from about 84 a year earlier. In its November 5 market update, NWMLS quoted Steven Bourassa, director of the Washington Center for Real Estate Research: "Interest rates rose even further, fueled by high inflation. Thirty-year mortgage interest rates averaged 7.33% in October versus 6.86% in September, a rise of nearly half a percentage point." Rates have come down a little since then. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026, down from 7.18% the week before.
Buyers also spread their time across more homes. The same NWMLS update counted 92,740 showings across the region in October, down 13.3% from a year earlier while active listings rose 25.2%. Each listing that was shown averaged 4.0 showings, down from 4.9.
Why Months of Inventory Understates the Supply
NWMLS calculates months of inventory by dividing month-end active listings by that month's closed sales. Every October closing began as a contract signed earlier, and the months before October had more contracts than October did. October's months-of-inventory figures are therefore measured against closings, and not against the slower contract pace of the month itself.
Using the same active listings with October's pending sales instead of its closings gives very different results. South Whidbey's 119 listings against 25 pending sales is about 4.8 months instead of 3.05. North Whidbey's 163 against 30 is about 5.4. Coupeville–Greenbank's 52 against 9 is about 5.8, and the county's 465 against 90 is about 5.2. This is our own arithmetic, not an NWMLS statistic, and some homes that went pending will not close. Still, if the slow October contract pace carries into November and December closings, the official figure will rise toward these numbers. That would show up in reports published in the new year, after a winter search has already begun.
North Whidbey Had the Most to Choose From First
Supply in Oak Harbor and the rest of Area 813 started growing before the drop in contracts. In August 2026, North Whidbey had 5.00 months of inventory and 175 active listings, compared with 139 listings a year earlier. In September it reached 5.19 months, with 166 active listings compared with 135. By the end of October, active listings were up 29.4% year over year to 163, the largest increase of the three Whidbey areas.
North Whidbey's October median still rose 9.1% to $507,500. In January, the South Whidbey Record reported that a consistent Navy presence and limited housing have generally kept Whidbey's market steady, and that North End homes in 2025 often sold in about 35 days or less. Steady demand and a rising median help explain how prices held up even with more listings. For a buyer, it means North Whidbey has more homes to choose from, though its prices have not softened.
Central Whidbey's Median Is Too Small a Sample to Read
Coupeville–Greenbank had 10 closings in October 2026, the same as October 2025. Its median fell 11.9% to $612,499. With only ten sales, one or two waterfront or acreage closings can move the median sharply in either direction. In September the area had 18 closings against 12 a year earlier, and its median was $621,500 against $737,500. Central Whidbey's month-to-month medians mostly reflect which homes happened to close. In October, its 52 active listings and nine pending sales give a clearer picture than its median does.
South Whidbey Depends on Price Range
Langley, Freeland and Clinton make up Area 811. It had the highest October median on the island at $791,000 and the lowest official months of inventory at 3.05. Its pending sales fell 46.8%, the steepest drop of the three areas. A breakdown by price shows where those closings and listings sit.
NWMLS area survey figures for South Whidbey show 35 closings in the 30 days ending October 20, 2026. Fourteen closed between $1 million and $2 million, against 35 homes listed in that range on October 20. The range between $800,000 and $1 million had 3 closings against 29 listings. Homes listed at $2 million and up had 11 listings and no closings in that window. Below $800,000, there were 18 closings against 50 listings. These are small counts and can shift within a single month. Even so, the South End looks like several separate markets with very different supply.
Prices have adjusted too. In September 2026, South Whidbey homes sold for about 97% of their final asking price, down from 99% in August, and for about 95% of their original asking price, down from 97%. In 2025, the South Whidbey Record reported that most of the island's luxury homes are on the South End and that luxury demand is especially sensitive to economic changes. In South Whidbey this fall, the $2 million-and-up range had listings and no recent closings. Among the ranges with sales, the $800,000 to $1 million range had the most listings per closing, and the $1 million to $2 million range had the most sales.
If you're weighing the island's towns for daily life rather than by these numbers, our guide on choosing between Whidbey's village hubs and our post on how the ferry shapes home demand cover what the market reports leave out.
Questions We Hear About These Numbers
Does a rising median in Oak Harbor mean prices there are still climbing? The October median reflects 38 closings, each of them a contract signed before or during October. North Whidbey's pending sales fell 44.4% in October 2026 while its listings grew 29.4%, so the median trails what buyers were doing in October.
Did prices drop 12% in Coupeville and Greenbank? The October 2026 median was $612,499 based on 10 sales, and September's was $621,500 on 18 sales, both below a year earlier. Those two months point the same way, but on 28 combined sales, a few waterfront or acreage closings can move either figure.
How long does a South Whidbey listing sit before a buyer has room to negotiate? That depends on the home, its price range and the competing listings. Our post on what days on market means explains how to read a listing's history, and writing a competitive offer covers the offer itself.
If you're deciding between the North, Central and South ends this winter, Team Langley can look at the pending sales and listings in your price range in each area with you, so you can see where you'll have the most homes to choose from. Start your island story by scheduling a consultation, or browse current Whidbey Island listings with these numbers in mind.